mindstalk: (Default)
Another chapter of the Indus book, due to travel to song circle. A lot of it is just the author going on a pathetic boat ride up the river. Cheap falling-apart boat, depressing and depressed river with little water in it.

In 1635, the English couldn't sell anything to the Sindh. The passage is unclear, so Italian goods might have sold, but not English ones; they had to trade silver for Indian cloth.

Anyone with a classical education knew of the Indus, but the British didn't know much *about* the Indus for a surprisingly long time. Even after the Ganges had been thoroughly subjected and exploited, Company maps didn't even have the right mouth for the Indus, let alone stuff on the valley or source.

Eventually they fixed that and conquered that valley too, to much actual moral outrage back home. And disasters, as well; troops were shocked that the virgins of Kabul did not strew their path with flowers in gratitude for overthrowing their native rulers. The river turned out to not be as navigable as boosters had claimed, either. But the 1857 "Mutiny" turned public support back to India, and the Sindh (lower Indus) and Punjab (upper, loosely speaking) had been 'loyal'.

Much damming occurred. Not one drop of water should be wasted in flowing out into the Arabian sea! So dams and canals were built, water was diverted ot wheat and cotton fields in the north... and away from rice fields and mangrove swamps (with shrimp) in the south, which got invaded by ocean salt instead. The delta shrank from 3500 to 250 square km. Farmers turned into fishermen. And Pakistan has continued the trend, plus extra sewage.
mindstalk: (Default)
As I said, this book made for more portable reading in my journeys to Boskone. It's now on the back burner -- late fees for interlibrary loan are apparently $2/day -- but I got some stuff out of it.

* India is named for the Indus, which is in Pakistan. I've mentioned that last year, in the History of India sequence, but thought I'd marvel at it again.

* "Pakistan" means land of the pure. The country's founder, Muhammad Ali Jinnah, expected the other country would go with the ancient Sanskrit equivalent, Bharat, and was incensed when they went with British "India" instead, making Pakistan seem like the carved off rump it was.
* Not at all clear why Partition erupted so violently. But it did.
* Muslim purity ideas + Hindu caste purity ideas = Pakistani Muslims will not clean toilets or fix sewers. Karachi went from "Asia's cleanest city" with streets washed daily to, uh, not, with rubbish-lined streets and foul streams. Fortunately there's Hindu and Christian[1] untouchables. But they started leaving, for some odd reason. Naturally Pakistan reacted by paying them attractive wages urging them to stay and trying to prevent them from leaving. Today the invaluable people who keep civilization from drowning in its own filth live in nice middle class homes a few hours beyond the last reach of domestic electricity.

[1] As I mentioned before, caste transcends religion; converting doesn't stop people from viewing you as low caste, no matter who does the converting. The one exception seems to be Buddhism.

* AFAICT the only people who benefited from Partition were Pakistani elites and Hindu extremists. Otherwise it was a total clusterfuck.
* Jinnah wasn't all that religious, keeping dogs and smoking cigarettes, not that you'd know it from his national hagiography. He also gave speeches promising religious freedom in the new state; this is also censored.

I note that Pakistan was founded in 1947, a year before Israel. Some parallels, founded at similar times for vaguely similar reasons for religious separation and ethnic 'protection'. OTOH Israel is infinitely more democratic and functional, and if you're thinking of the occupied territories, Pakistan has its genocides in Bangladesh.

Profile

mindstalk: (Default)
mindstalk

May 2025

S M T W T F S
    123
45678910
11 121314151617
1819202122 2324
25262728293031

Most Popular Tags

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Style Credit

Page generated 2025-05-24 23:22
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios